How to Choose an SEO Agency: 12 Questions to Ask

To choose an SEO agency, ask twelve questions about goals, people, process, reporting and contracts, then compare the written answers from two or three providers. A good agency explains what it will do each month, who will do it, how you will see results, and how you can leave. Avoid anyone who guarantees rankings or will not share details.
What are the 12 questions to ask an SEO agency?
The twelve questions below cover the topics that matter most. Ask every agency the same ones, in writing if you can, so that you can compare answers side by side.
- What do you need to know about my business before you recommend a plan?
- What goals will you work toward, and how will we measure them?
- What will you do in the first 90 days?
- Who will work on my account, and what is their experience?
- How do you research keywords and decide which pages to improve?
- How do you build links, and what do you refuse to do?
- What will you create each month: pages, articles, fixes, links?
- What will your reports show, and where does the data come from?
- How often will we talk, and who is my contact?
- What is the price, and what is not included?
- What is the contract length, and how do I cancel?
- Who owns the content, accounts and data if we stop?
The sections below explain why each one matters and what a good answer sounds like. Rank Ray is an SEO and AI search agency, founded in 2019 by Own-ur-Rehman Sheikh, working remotely with US businesses. We have no US office. You can use these questions on us as well.
What should you ask about strategy and goals?
Ask the agency to explain how it will connect SEO to your business goals. Questions one to three test whether the agency listens first or sells first. A strong agency asks about your customers, your services, your margins and your competition before it names a plan.
1. What do you need to know about my business? Good agencies ask many questions. They want to know what you sell, who buys, which products or services make the most money and where you operate. If the agency sends a package after one short call, be careful.
2. What goals will you work toward? The goals should be about the business: calls, leads, sales or booked appointments. Rankings and traffic matter, but they are steps toward those outcomes. Ask how you will measure progress and how you will compare it against a baseline.
3. What will you do in the first 90 days? Expect a plan with an audit or review, fixes, a keyword plan and early content or local work. SEO takes time, but you should see clear activity from the start. Google also reminds site owners in its guidance on SEO help to be skeptical of promises of instant results.
What should you ask about people and process?
Ask who will do the work and how they decide what to do. Questions four to six test the depth of the team and the quality of its methods. You are hiring people, not a brand name.
4. Who works on my account? Ask for roles and experience. Find out whether the person on the sales call will also do the work. Ask what happens when someone is out. A written answer helps.
5. How do you choose keywords and pages? A good agency starts with how your customers search and then maps keywords to pages. It should explain how it handles search intent, local terms and pages you already have. Be wary of keyword lists with no link to your services.
6. How do you build links, and what do you refuse to do? Good answers describe outreach, real content and relationships with relevant sites. The agency should refuse private blog networks, paid link schemes and fake reviews. If the answer is vague, ask for examples of the types of sites they pursue. You can see how we describe our approach on our link building page.
What should you ask about deliverables and reporting?
Ask for a list of what you will receive each month and a sample report. Questions seven to nine show whether you will be able to see the work and judge it. Vague deliverables are a common source of disputes later.
7. What will you create each month? Look for specific items: number of articles, pages updated, fixes made and links built. Quantity is not everything, so also ask how the agency checks quality.
8. What will your reports show? Reports should come from data you can access, such as Google Search Console, Google Analytics and your Business Profile. They should show actions taken, results and next steps. Ask for access to the same accounts so you can check the numbers yourself.
9. How often will we talk? A monthly call and a quick way to ask questions is a common setup. Ask for the name of your main contact and the usual response time.
| Question | Strong answer | Weak answer |
|---|---|---|
| Deliverables | Itemized monthly list | “Ongoing optimization” |
| Reporting | Your own Google data | A private dashboard only |
| Contact | Named person, set cadence | Generic support inbox |
| Links | Real sites, listed in reports | “Proprietary network” |
What should you ask about price, contracts and ownership?
Ask for the price in writing, the length of the contract and who owns the work. Questions ten to twelve protect you if the relationship does not work out. Clear answers here are a sign of a fair provider.
10. What is the price, and what is not included? Ask for a scope that lists inclusions and exclusions. Rank Ray publishes its prices: Local SEO is $1,500 a month, Growth SEO is $2,500 a month and Authority SEO is from $4,000 a month. See the details on our SEO packages page. Market prices vary widely, so compare what each quote covers, not only the fee.
11. What is the contract length, and how do I cancel? Some agencies require long terms. Ours has a three month minimum, then month to month. Whatever the term is, make sure the cancellation steps are written down.
12. Who owns the content, accounts and data? You should own your website, content, Google accounts and reports. An agency should work inside your accounts, not hold them hostage. Ask what you will receive if you leave.
How do you compare agencies after the calls?
Put the answers side by side and score them on clarity, fit and trust. Do not decide on the cheapest price or the most confident pitch. Choose the agency whose answers are specific, honest and easy to verify.
- Create a simple sheet with the twelve questions in rows and each agency in columns.
- Fill in the answers from the calls and proposals.
- Mark answers that were vague, missing or too good to be true.
- Check references or examples, if the agency offers them.
- Look at the agency’s own site and content. Do they explain things clearly?
- Pick your top two and ask any follow-up questions.
- Choose the one you trust, and start with the minimum term.
Pay attention to how the agency handles your questions. A good partner will not mind detailed ones. If you receive pressure to sign quickly, pause. Real SEO work does not depend on a countdown.
What should you prepare before the first call?
Prepare a short brief so the call is useful. Agencies give better answers when you share the facts. It also helps you see which providers ask good questions in return.
- Your website address and any other sites you run.
- The products or services that make you the most money.
- The places you serve, such as one city, several cities or the whole country.
- Your main competitors, as you see them.
- Your current results: leads, sales or calls, and where they come from.
- Past SEO work, including anyone you hired before and what happened.
- Your budget range and the date you want to start.
Make sure you have access to your Google Search Console, Google Analytics and Business Profile accounts, or know who does. Without access, nobody can give you a grounded view of where you stand.
What does a good first month look like?
A good first month is mostly setup, review and early fixes. You should see an audit or review of your site, access to the right accounts, a baseline of your current results and a plan for the following months. You may also see quick wins, such as corrected titles, a cleaned-up Business Profile or fixes for crawl errors.
| Week | Typical activity | What you should receive |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Access, goals, baseline | Kickoff notes and a data snapshot |
| 2 | Audit and keyword work | Findings and a priority list |
| 3 | First fixes and content plan | A change log and a content calendar |
| 4 | Review and next steps | A written report and a call |
If the first month brings only a welcome email and an invoice, ask what is happening. Even in slow-burn work like SEO, you should be able to point to actions taken.
How long should the selection process take?
Allow two to four weeks for a careful decision. That gives you time to share a brief, hold calls, receive proposals and ask follow-up questions. A rushed choice is the most common cause of regret.
Do not feel pressured to decide on the first call. A good agency will give you space. If you want a lower-risk way to test a provider, start with a project such as an audit before committing to a monthly plan. You will learn how the team thinks, how it communicates and whether its recommendations make sense for your business.
Which red flags should make you walk away?
Walk away from guaranteed rankings, secret methods, no access to your accounts and pressure to sign fast. These are signs of a provider that may put its interests ahead of yours.
- A promise of a number one ranking or a fixed date.
- Refusal to explain what they will do.
- Reports that show only traffic or rankings with no business results.
- Links from networks that the agency will not describe.
- Contracts that hide cancellation terms or ownership.
Review Google’s SEO starter guide so that you know the basics. An informed buyer is hard to mislead.
Should you choose a local agency or a remote one?
Both can work. SEO is done online, and most agencies work with clients remotely. What matters is responsiveness, knowledge of your market and clear communication. A nearby agency may meet in person, but a remote one can have more specialist skills.
Rank Ray works remotely with clients across the country and has no US office. If local knowledge matters to you, ask how an agency researches your area and what it knows about your competitors. You can see how we write about specific markets on our New York SEO agency page.
Frequently asked questions
How many agencies should I talk to?
Two or three is enough for most businesses. Fewer limits your view of the market. More can waste time. Ask each the same questions so that the comparison is fair.
Should I ask for case studies?
Yes, but read them with care. Ask what the starting point was, what was done, and how the results were measured. Results from one business may not apply to yours. Be wary of case studies with no details.
What if an agency will not share its methods?
That is a red flag. An agency does not need to give away every detail, but it should be able to explain what it will do and why. Secret methods make it hard to know if you are at risk.
Is a free audit a good way to start?
It can be, but free audits are often sales tools. A paid audit with a ranked fix list gives you something useful whether or not you hire the provider. Ours starts at $750 for sites under 500 pages. See our SEO audit service.
How soon should I expect results?
SEO usually takes several months to show clear results, depending on your market and starting point. Early months focus on fixes and setup. Ask the agency what progress you should see at 30, 60 and 90 days.
Ready to put these questions to us?
We welcome tough questions. Request a quote from Rank Ray, and ask us all twelve.
Recent Articles
